Thypoch Simera 28mm F1.4 M-Mount Review | Does it Have the Leica Vibe?
Jan 16, 2024
Photographer Dustin Abbott shares a thorough, real world review of the new Simera 28mm F1.4 for Leica M-mount from new lensmaker Thypoch | Read the Text Review: | Visit the Image Gallery: | Purchase the Thypoch Simera 28mm F1.4 @ B&H Photo https://bhpho.to/48z58lI or Adorama https://howl.me/clpJirCHdU5
Check out the DA Merch here: https://bit.ly/TWIMerch | Become a Patron: https://www.patreon.com/dustinabbott | On the Web: http://dustinabbott.net/ | Sign up for my Newsletter: http://bit.ly/1RHvUNp | Instagram: http://bit.ly/DLAinsta | Facebook: http://on.fb.me/1nuUUeH | Flickr: http://bit.ly/1UcnC0B | 500px: http://bit.ly/1Sy2Ngu Follow Craig @ https://www.instagram.com/craigstoffersen/
Want to support this channel? Use these affiliate links to shop at:
B&H Photo: http://bhpho.to/1TA0Xge
Adorama: https://howl.me/cjU0LKdp3LN
Camera Canada: http://bit.ly/DLACameraCan
Sony Canada: https://www.thesonyshop.ca/?ref=abbott
Amazon: https://amzn.to/3HrY64d
Amazon Canada: https://amzn.to/3qG1p18
Ebay: http://bit.ly/DustineBay
Into the AM Clothing: https://bit.ly/intotheAMda and use code DUSTIN10 for 10% off
Make a donation via Paypal: https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/dustinTWI
=============================
Table of Contents:
=============================
0:00 - Who is Thypoch?
1:20 - Fantom Wallets
2:06 - Build and Design
7:40 - Image Quality Overview
12:35 - Conclusion and Pricing
14:06 - Optical Deep Dive
---------------------------------------------------------
Oben Tabletop Tripod shown in video: https://bhpho.to/3vL8YWy
My Cameras:
Purchase the Sony a7RV @ B&H Photo https://bhpho.to/3ZivNyZ | Adorama https://howl.me/cjNY1LU3gFH | Amazon https://amzn.to/3CRCDlq | Camera Canada https://shrsl.com/3vulf | Sony Canada https://bit.ly/BuyA7R5 | Amazon Canada https://amzn.to/3H8yeNH | Amazon UK https://amzn.to/3kbg5FM
Purchase the Sony Alpha 1 @ Camera Canada https://shrsl.com/2wdk2 | B&H Photo https://bhpho.to/3upRFZd | Adorama https://howl.me/cj2nQpjLBKW | Amazon https://amzn.to/3t1m8MD | Sony Canada https://bit.ly/BuySonyA1 |Amazon Canada https://amzn.to/3cVFrBB | Amazon UK https://amzn.to/2OtrjGe | Amazon Germany https://amzn.to/3d0GtMO | Ebay https://ebay.us/i371Vs
Canon EOS R5: B&H Photo https://bhpho.to/3iMH18x | Amazon https://amzn.to/33L3D53 | Camera Canada https://shrsl.com/2jqth
Purchase the Fujifilm X-H2 @ B&H Photo https://bhpho.to/3KAInTC | Adorama https://howl.me/cjyzbiO5lVp | Amazon https://amzn.to/41zMzKl | Camera Canada https://shrsl.com/4128o | Amazon Canada https://amzn.to/40gY4W7 | Amazon UK https://amzn.to/43Grn7a | Amazon Germany https://amzn.to/3L6hwjR
Get a discount off all Skylum Editing Software (Luminar, Aurora HDR, AirMagic) by using code DUSTINHDR at checkout: http://bit.ly/LuminarDLA
DISCLAIMER: This video and description contains affiliate links, which means that if you click on one of the product links, I’ll receive a small commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Keywords: Thypoch, Simera, 28mm, F1.4, Simera 28, 35mm, M-mount, Rangefinder, Techart, LM-EA9, LMEA9, Techart LM-EA9 Review, LM-EA7, Leica M to E, Full Frame, Review, Sony Alpha 1, Sony a7RV, Review, Hands On, Dustin Abbott, Real World, Comparison, Sharpness, Bokeh, Flare Resistance, Autofocus, Image Quality, Sample Images, Video, Photography, let the light in, #letthelightin, DA
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
Hi, I'm Dustin Abbott and I'm here today to give you a look at a brand new lens from a
0:15
brand new lens maker. The company Typoc is a new lens maker that is targeting the Leica M mount rangefinder
0:23
crowd with their new Samara lineup of manual lenses. Now the initial releases are a 28mm and a 35mm f1.4 lenses and they do only come in
0:35
Leica M mount. The names Typoc which is a combination of two old English words and then Samara which
0:42
is a Greek word, they focus on individuality and living in the moment
0:47
Now obviously that's completely marketing but it does reflect the fact that Typoc is
0:52
going after that Leica vibe and trying to capture both the kind of the aesthetic and
0:58
the lifestyle and then the overall feel of the lenses in the release of the Samara lineup
1:03
So the question is as we look at the Samara 28mm f1.4 as the focus of today's review
1:10
have they nailed that Leica feel as a part of their design and the optical performance
1:16
Well let's dive in and find out right after a word from our sponsor
1:21
Today's episode is brought to you by Phantom Wallet, the minimalist modern wallet that
1:25
is now even better with the new Phantom X that is crafted from aluminum right here in Canada
1:31
It is 22% smaller and 35% lighter while still making it easy to access your cards and money
1:37
when you need them thanks to their unique fanning mechanism. You could even customize your wallet due to its modular design with accessories like a
1:45
money clip, cash holder, ID display and even Chipolo and AirTag tracking integration
1:51
Visit store.phantomwallet.com to check out their unique sizes, styles and finishes that
1:57
span from aluminum to wood to carbon fiber and use code Dustin15 for 15% off when you're
2:03
ready to check out. So as you can see I'm looking at the silver version of the Samara 28mm f1.4 but both the
2:13
28mm and 35mm do come in both black and silver editions. The MSRP for these lenses is $699 and if that seems expensive to you for a manual focus
2:27
compact lens like this, bear in mind that the Leica Summilux M 28mm f1.4 retails for
2:33
$7800 and so this lens is literally more than 11 times cheaper than what that lens is
2:42
But you wouldn't know it from the build quality. Everything is all metal here which includes by the way the caps and the hood which are
2:50
frankly the rear cap is maybe one of the nicest that I've ever seen
2:54
But everything here does have a lot of attention to detail. Now as noted the lens hood is all made of metal
3:01
It is kind of the rectangular style that you do see on a lot of Leica lenses kind of following
3:05
that old rangefinder aesthetic. But I will note that there is a limitation that comes as a part of that in that the front
3:12
cap is a slip over style and so if you are using the front cap it's either that or the
3:19
lens hood because you can't use both at the same time. So the aesthetic may look cool but there is a price to pay for in this case I think that
3:28
style is trumping over functionality. Now the lens is very very compact here
3:34
It is 54mm in diameter that's 2.1 inches and it has a very compact 49mm front filter
3:42
thread which seems to be a pretty common one amongst Leica M mount 28mm lenses
3:48
Now the lens is 55mm just 1mm longer in its overall length that's 2.2 inches and it weighs
3:55
in at 330 grams or 11.6 ounces. So that's about 110 grams less than the aforementioned Leica Summilux lens and so obviously if you
4:06
are looking to travel light getting the f1.4 aperture and an all metal build while also
4:11
staying fairly lightweight is an added bonus here. Now this is a manual everything lens which is pretty common on Leica and the rangefinder
4:20
bodies but everything is nicely executed here. The manual focus ring has really nice, it's all in metal of course, and it has really
4:28
nice knurled sections that each have individualized grip so very easy to grip
4:34
The focus ring moves very very smoothly and there is a couple of unique features here
4:40
There is a little bit of additional drag that is at 0.7m, minimum focus distance is 0.4m
4:46
but at 0.7m there is some additional drag and the intent of that is that on rangefinder
4:51
bodies that's as close as they will actually focus and so beyond that you have to switch
4:56
to live view if you want to get accurate focus up close. So it's designed to just kind of let you know you are entering into that territory
5:02
On the other end of the approximately 100-110 degrees of focus rotation there is actually
5:09
an infinity lock there. I'm not convinced that it's entirely necessary but it is a cool looking feature
5:16
You do have to, once it's in that lock position you have to just depress this little tension
5:22
knob here and so it will release to allow you to rotate back out of there
5:26
This is an internally focusing lens which does actually set it apart as superior in
5:31
fact to some of the Leica counterparts. The lens has a nicely executed aperture ring near the front of the lens and so you have
5:39
a couple of different options. Surprisingly you actually have a click-declip click option on this lens and so you can choose
5:47
to click it and you will have 1 third stop to tenths that are really nicely defined all
5:52
the way through F8. After F8 you have single stop to tenths for F11 and F16
5:59
Now if you're in the declick mode obviously you can smoothly rack through that entire
6:05
aperture iris range and as you can see here the other bonus here is there is a beautiful
6:10
14-bladed aperture iris that stays really beautifully round as you open and close it
6:16
And so that is a very, very nice addition. Kind of another cool, I almost call it an Easter egg here, that I didn't initially notice
6:24
but only noticed after using it for a while and that is that rather than having a traditional
6:28
hyperfocus scale, instead what you have is you have these little red dots that start
6:34
to fill in as you stop the lens down. And so each one of those corresponds to the position where you can put the infinity symbol
6:43
if you're wanting to achieve proper hyperfocal distance. And so just kind of a unique bespoke touch there that I found very, very cool
6:52
Now as noted previously the minimum focus distance is 0.4 meters or 40 centimeters
6:58
That is not particularly close for a 28mm lens though in many cases close focus doesn't
7:04
seem to be a priority with a lot of the Leica lenses
7:08
But in this case you have roughly a 0.09x magnification which as you can see is not
7:14
particularly high. The build quality however is actually really, really nice. Everything is very beautifully executed here and there's a really fine attention to detail
7:23
which I appreciate. For those that appreciate lenses that are also kind of engineered pieces of art, this
7:30
is something that will probably delight you both in the tactile sense but also in the
7:34
overall aesthetic look. They're great looking lenses and they handle very nicely
7:39
Now image quality here comes via an optical formula of 11 elements in 7 groups
7:45
Now that includes an ED element, an aspherical element and 3 HR or high refractive index
7:52
elements as a part of the design. Another welcome surprise as a part of the optical design is a floating element that
7:58
allows you to get better performance up close. And again it's that attention to detail that has impressed me as a part of this brand new
8:05
lensmaker and their design. So we'll give you a quick breakdown of overall performance here
8:12
You can see from the MTF chart that we've got a good performance in the center of the
8:17
frame, a pretty good performance mid-frame and then weaker corner performance and a little
8:23
bit of improvement across the board as you stop it down. We're going to break all the optical performance down in detail at the end of the review so
8:29
stay tuned for that if you're interested in the kind of nitty gritty of the details
8:33
If you just want the overview I'll give you just a quick rundown of optical performance
8:38
in my experience. So the first positive note is there's basically no distortion here
8:42
I could do a tiny correction of maybe a minus one but frankly you probably wouldn't even
8:47
notice in any kind of real world conditions. Vignette on the other hand is heavier
8:51
We've got about three stops of vignette in the corners. It improves a little bit as you stop down but it never goes away altogether
8:59
Again positive is there is very good control of aberrations on the 28mm which by the way
9:04
is better in this than the 35mm. So I saw almost no longitudinal chromatic aberrations, very very minimal fringing before
9:11
and after the plane of focus. I also saw basically no lateral chromatic aberrations near the corners of the frame
9:18
so that's a very strong performance when it comes to that. If we look at the overall sharpness and contrast we find breaking it down and this is at 200
9:27
magnification so yes, torture test and I reviewed on 61 megapixels of resolution actually used
9:33
both a manual adapter and then the TechArt LM-EA9 adapter which gives you a little bit
9:39
of auto focus. It gives you M-mount lenses on Sony E-mount. I don't own a Leica body and so I was testing on a 61 megapixel Sony A7R Mark V for these
9:50
tests just so you know and so I found that there was good center performance, there was
9:54
okay mid performance and there was fairly weak corner performance. Now I did find that real world results looked a little bit better mostly because you're
10:02
not composing the extreme corners at f1.4 in real world shots typically but also because
10:08
the lens has such nice rendering that I just like the overall results and so it gave me
10:13
a more positive feel. The center will become very crisp by f2, the mid frame very crisp by f4 and the corners
10:22
very crisp by f5.6 so you can if you wanted to use this lens as a landscape lens you could
10:28
do so after you stop it down. I found kind of peak consistent performance across the frame at f8 and there is after
10:37
that diffraction will start to slightly soften the image but even by f16 which is minimum
10:42
aperture I really didn't find that the images looked too bad. The bokeh from this lens is actually really nice so looking at it on the technical side
10:50
first there is of the geometry there's a little bit of cat eye you know deformation near the
10:57
corners of the frame with specular highlights in some cases that will give you a little
11:01
bit of that swirl effect you'll either like or dislike that depending on your taste
11:06
By f2 it's almost perfectly round all across the frame and because remember there's that
11:11
14 bladed aperture iris after that point if you can create specular highlights or bokeh
11:16
balls you will find that they tend to be really nice and circular because that aperture blades
11:21
is so nice and circular. In situations where you don't have specular highlights and it's more just about a creamy
11:27
background I found that up close you could get a really nice and creamy background and
11:32
even at more medium distances I found that the kind of what I call the transition zone
11:38
was actually handled fairly well. So bokeh quality from the lens and the overall look and rendering I think is quite nice
11:45
The lens also exhibited surprisingly good flare resistance wide open with like light
11:51
coming through the windows I found that what bit of kind of veiling was there was actually
11:56
quite artistic kind of gave a warm glow to images and then directly facing into the sun
12:01
even when stopping down I saw just a basically one kind of ghosting artifact that wasn't
12:06
too big and not too destructive so positive there. I did test for coma though in using the tech art it's a little bit tough sometimes to nail
12:14
infinity focus in that kind of setting the movement of the actual adapter could kind
12:20
of work against you so my results are not perfectly focused however what I did find
12:25
is that there is a little bit of coma smear in the corners it's not terrible but this
12:31
lens wouldn't be what I would call a top astrophotography pick either
12:36
In general I really liked the look of the images that I got from the Typoc Samara 28mm
12:42
f1.4 and so in summation I think that Typoc has really done a pretty good job here of
12:48
nailing a lot of the Leica aesthetic and the lens design but also a lot of the Leica aesthetic
12:54
when it comes to the image quality and obviously at a much much lower price point
12:58
I enjoyed using the Samara 28mm f1.4 I will confess I do have a little bit of a weakness
13:04
for nicely executed manual focus lenses and in this case I think that that's what they've
13:09
done so I enjoyed using the lens I think the question remains of how the market is going
13:14
to receive this. The Leica brand is unique amongst most modern photography brands and those who have bought
13:21
into the Leica system I don't know for sure whether they're open to a non-established
13:27
brand like this. Maybe they are and obviously there's always going to be some disparity of opinion across
13:35
any kind of group of photographers but I guess the market will determine whether or not people
13:41
are looking for an off-brand lens like this new Typoc lens for their Leica body
13:49
But if you happen to be open to a far less expensive alternative for your Leica body
13:54
take a look at the Typoc Samara 28mm f1.4 if you like 28mm this is a pretty nice one
14:01
Now if you want to go into a deeper dive of the optical performance stay tuned we're going to jump into that right after this
14:15
Okay let's take a deeper dive into the image quality performance starting with the vignette
14:19
and distortion. You can see that this the uncorrected image on the left that there is basically almost
14:25
nothing to correct there as far as the distortion very very minimal I do use a minus one here
14:30
on the right but you really can't hardly tell a difference. Vignette is much more obvious
14:35
I used a plus 73 to correct for the vignette and the corners and move the midpoint most
14:40
of the way over. You can see that gave us a nice clean up that's about three stops
14:46
Now many wide aperture lenses like this do suffer from longitudinal chromatic aberrations
14:50
but that's really not much of an issue here as you can see there is just a tiny bit of
14:55
friending fringing before and after the plane of focus it is not very pronounced at all
14:59
and if I take a look at something like this with shiny and reflective surfaces I can see
15:05
yes just the tiniest bits of fringing but as we go towards the bokeh highlights very
15:10
minimal there and as we move out of focus I see only just the slightest bit of fringing
15:16
but not enough that you're really going to notice it on the whole image at all
15:21
Lateral chromatic aberrations are even if anything are less pronounced and you can see
15:25
in these transitions from black to white near the edge of the frame that everything is really
15:29
really nice and clean. So as noted previously I'm doing this test on a 61 megapixel Sony a7r mark 5 so very
15:38
high resolution level. I'm showing you these results at 200% so we can see that wide open contrast isn't perfect
15:45
but there is a lot of detail there in the center of the frame looking really quite good
15:49
I'm going to go to the left here and we can see that the mid-frame looks again its contrast
15:56
is not fantastic but there is a good amount of detail that's being captured there and
16:00
down here on the left side we can see that you know there's still some work to do in
16:05
the corners but there is it's not like there's no image quality here either
16:09
As noted in my summary I kind of liked my real world results even better than what that suggests
16:15
For one thing if you're looking just at a hundred percent magnification level that really
16:19
looks quite good. There's no issues there with the detail that I'm seeing and moreover just the overall look
16:26
and rendering of the image looks quite good here in my sauna and so you can see it's handling
16:31
the light coming through the window there quite well and if we look here obviously it's
16:37
going to be a fairly narrow depth of field you can see it's not pen sharp but there's
16:42
plenty there to make this image look credible and thus overall I really like the look of
16:48
the image. One final here and I can't remember if this was f1.4 or f1.8 but you can see here I wanted
16:55
to use a shallow depth field and use the contrast of this old abandoned barn with the kind of
17:02
the whiteout around it of the fresh snow and if we punch in there to a pixel level you
17:07
can see again it's not what I would call pen sharp but you can see there's a perfectly
17:12
usable amount of detail and I like the look of the image overall
17:16
Now stopping down to f1.8 does give us more contrast in the center of the frame over in
17:23
the mid frame the results again there's a little bit more contrast there and you can
17:27
see that the brighter areas are brighter to the corners it's not enough to really improve
17:32
the resolution much but again you can see that contrast is improved some with some brighter
17:38
looking edges. Now f1.8 to f2 makes a more marked improvement in the contrast in the center of the frame
17:45
with the center looking what I would consider pretty much pen sharp at this point the mid
17:49
frame is also improving and looking better not a hundred percent there yet and the corners
17:55
not a huge leap ahead yet there. By f2.8 to f4 you know even at f2.8 here we can see that the details looking really really
18:04
good contrast is looking excellent and if I pop down here once again and I look towards
18:09
the edge you can see it is starting to improve and it's going to be better still if we stop
18:14
down to f4 and then to f5.6 where the corners are looking really fantastic now
18:21
So for landscape type shots where you're looking for detail all across the frame you know if
18:26
you stop it down in this case I wouldn't call the corners looking as good on 61 megapixels
18:32
but overall the image looks nice and crisp I mean it's an image you would be perfectly
18:37
happy with. Here's another shot here that even if we look into the foreground everything looks really
18:42
nice and then as we look on towards infinity everything is captured looking really nicely
18:48
right off to the edge of the frame and so here's an image that I feel like really held
18:53
up well and shows off what the lens is capable of. So after f8 diffraction will start in a little bit at f11 though you can see it still looks
19:01
really good and then minimum aperture of f16 you can see by comparison that it is softer
19:07
but it's not unusable either and you can see even down into the corners that there still
19:12
is a useful amount of information so I wouldn't be against using that even at f16
19:18
Now as noted previously our minimum focus distance is only 40 centimeters and so magnification
19:24
isn't super high. Detail doesn't look too bad here up close however it's still what I would consider usable
19:31
for sure. A quick closer look at that bokeh geometry you can see that we're definitely getting
19:36
some of that lemon shape towards the corners of the frame if I stop down to f2 it's not
19:41
completely circular but you can see it looks acceptably circular by f2.8 everything is
19:47
looking better and of course you're going to continue to have really nice results due
19:51
to having that really circular aperture. We can also see because of low chromatic aberrations and a good amount of contrast that there's
19:59
a great amount of detail that's there even on some of these shiny and reflective surfaces
20:04
Now of course the lens doesn't focus particularly close I was able to get a little bit closer
20:09
due to using the tech art adapter that is one advantage of that but you can see that
20:14
the detail is good there but I mean this is obviously a really creamy type of background
20:19
here in this case at f1.4 where I'm back a little bit further you can see a little
20:24
bit of that swirl effect due to the specular highlights there so whether you like or dislike
20:29
that it's there. Now flare resistance was again quite good I really liked how it handled shots like this
20:36
which is important because this is the kind of shot that I would like to take with a lens
20:41
like this. So you've got some bright light coming through a window source and you can see that it's
20:46
everything's got a little bit of a warm glow but there's no kind of damage to the image
20:51
and this shot here once again backlit and so the sun's coming through fairly intensely
20:56
there but we can see at large aperture here that there's just a bit of a glow but there's
21:00
no big ghosting artifacts. As you stop down a bit you do get a little bit more of these kind of blobs but nothing
21:07
too severe and so I wasn't put off by that performance at all
21:12
And as noted with the caveat of not being able to focus perfectly for this we can see
21:17
that as we move off towards the edge of the frame you can see that the star points are
21:21
deforming a little bit and so they're becoming not quite like full-on flying birds but almost
21:27
a little triangular in shape and so that is the evidence of coma going on there and so
21:33
it's not a terrible performance but neither is it a good one either when it comes to coma
21:39
Overall however though I think that this lens really does pull off a very nice looking
21:43
optical performance. So thanks for watching to the end I hope that this has helped you to get a better understanding
21:50
of this lens and also this new brand. If you want more information you can check the link below in the description to my full
21:57
written review also there are buying links there if you'd like to pick one of these up
22:01
for yourself. As always thanks for watching have a great day and let the light in
Science

